Okay, I wanted to write a long blog post about this subject, but every time that I started to write, I got a little worked up and the words didn’t come out exactly the way that I wanted. So I am going to write them here. I ask that you read this whole post before you pass judgement, send me rude comments or debate me.
Earlier this morning I received an email from Change.org telling me that I might be interested in signing this petition. As I do with all emails from change.org, I clicked on the link to head over to the site to check it out. I am willing to give every petition a look, even if they are unlikely to accomplish what they are trying to accomplish, simply because it alerts me to issues that are occurring in our country and world that might interest me. So I read through the description of the petition and I am immediately torn. The petition was in regards to the annual Lychee and Dog Meat festival held in Yulin, China. The festival itself is new, but is rooted in a belief that dates back hundreds of years in the Chinese society. Chinese people have believed that the consumption of dog
would ward of heat in the upcoming summer months. The festival lasts around ten days and it is estimated that 10,000-15,000 dogs are consumed during the event.
Now, as a staunch dog lover and lover of animals, I was conflicted. The idea of eating a dog is, to me, outlandish. I could never see myself eating a dog during my lifetime, even if I was not a vegetarian. I have been raised and programmed to think of dogs as pets, companions and family members. To me, as to many other people in our society, a dog is not food. I was raised instead to see other animals as a more acceptable source of food – chickens, pigs, cows, turkeys. The idea of a steak dinner or a celebration centered around a cooked turkey don’t strike many of us as odd. Society tells us that these are what we should be eating.
So, this is the part that gets a little tricky. Just because I would not eat a dog, does not mean that others should not eat a dog. I was raised in a culture that taught me that dogs were not to be eaten, that they were to be taken care of and loved. But my culture is different from the culture in China. To those that have grown up in the Chinese culture, dogs can be viewed as meat. This is the point that we need to step back from our outrage and understand cultural differences. We do not have to agree with what is happening in other cultures, but we have to understand there are accepted norms that may be in stark contrast to ours. Not accepting and, more importantly, respecting these differences can expose us as judgemental, self righteous and xenophobic.
While we do not eat dog meat, we do participate in the consumption of beef quite frequently in this country. To Americans, the breeding, slaughter and consumption of cow is done without the blink of an eye. But to a large population of people in the world, the cow is an animal that should never be eaten, an animal that is considered sacred. As of 2012 there was around a billion Hindus in the world, all of whom who believed the cow to be a sacred animal and all of whom are directly opposed to the consumption of the animal. To those who practice Hinduism, our practice of eating beef can be seen in the same way that many in our country would view eating a dog.
“But dogs are highly intelligent and loyal animals. They’re not exactly on the same level as cows.”
Alright. I could argue about the cognitive abilities of cows that have been tested, but I will concede this point since dogs obviously show that they are on a different level intellectually than their bovine brethren. So we don’t eat dogs because they are smart and loyal animals. If that is the case let me pose this question, why do we as American eat pig then?
Pigs have been proven to be on the same level, if not above that of dogs intellectually. They have excellent long term memories, can understand symbolic language, exist in complex communities that allow them to learn from each other and they can even express empathy when another of their kind is feeling pain. I would be willing to say that some human could learn a little from them regarding empathy.
I am not here to advocate that everyone stops eating meat. While I believe that we as a society should curb our over-consumption of meat, it is not my place to tell anyone how to behave or what to eat. What I am asking, is that when a story such as the Yulin Dog Festival comes floating through your stream, you think a little bit about how the things you do and that you eat might be viewed by another society. Thinking about your own actions, respecting the views of another culture and not passing judgement simply because our values differ is the first step to truly understanding one another.